
Is This Thing On? is a 2025 American comedy-drama directed by Bradley Cooper, who also co-wrote the screenplay with Will Arnett (who also stars) and Mark Chappell. Loosely inspired by the life of comedian John Bishop, the film follows Alex (Arnett) and Tess Novak (Laura Dern), a long-married couple trying to navigate separation while co-parenting their two sons. As Alex unexpectedly drifts into stand-up comedy and Tess reconnects with her past as a volleyball athlete, the film explores divorce, reinvention, and the messy possibility of finding your way back to someone.
Although this movie deals with the (mostly amateur) standup comedy scene in New York City, it’s fairly lightweight as a comedy. You can’t really criticize Arnett’s character for not being hilarious, because it’s built into the story that he’s a newbie with no illusions of becoming a great comic. He uses comedy as self-expression and even therapy. To be fair, many professional standup comedians aren’t that different.
The movie goes back and forth between the two worlds of a struggling marriage and the comedy club subculture. While I don’t have firsthand knowledge of the comedy world, the way Alex is gradually accepted by his fellow comics and the way the audience halfheartedly laughs at his barely-planned jokes has an authentic ring. Similarly, the scenes between Arnett and Dern, as they go through cycles of anger, attraction, repulsion, and forgiveness, capture some of the messiness of real relationships.
As Alex goes back and forth between his apartment, visiting his kids, and working his comedy act, we never see what he does during the day. One of my pet peeves in movies and TV shows is characters who are seemingly immune to the everyday (primarily financial) concerns of most people. Alex and Tess own a home, somewhere on New York’s Metro North line (Westchester?), are raising kids, and we never see how they pay the bills.
Tess is recruited as a volleyball coach, but what was she doing before this? The only mention of Alex’s career is that he’s in “finance,” a single word that explains his ability to maintain a Manhattan apartment after moving out. For someone with a presumably demanding job, he has lots of free time and is able to keep nightclub (comedy club) hours. It was obviously a decision to not show anyone’s 9-5 rut, but this takes away from the realism.
There are strong supporting roles as well –Primarily Bradley Cooper himself as “Balls,” the mandatory goofy friend and Andra Day as his wife Christine.
Is This Thing On?, despite having a great cast (I don’t think I’ve ever disliked anything with Laura Dern) and an interesting storyline, is not the most entertaining or engaging film. I feel a little guilty saying this, as I agree with Time critic Stephanie Zacharek who says that this is the kind of movie Hollywood has forgotten how to make -one whose target audience is actually intelligent adults.
Is This Thing On? is not extremely long at just around two hours, but it probably would have flowed more smoothly if they’d cut 15 minutes or so. Nevertheless, it’s worth seeing if you like character-driven movies that maintain some degree of realism, something not very common these days.
Is This Thing On? is currently streaming on Hulu, Amazon Prime (costs extra), and other platforms.










